The city of beautiful nonsense — Text and Context
Edition facts
Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.
How this score is calculated
- Description quality20 pts
- Title & short description10 pts
- Source metadata20 pts
- Text length15 pts
- Chapters / structure15 pts
- EPUB file integrity20 pts
Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.
Read the Text
I. A Prelude on the Eve of St. Joseph’s Day II. The Last Candle III. The Greengrocer’s--Fetter Lane IV. What to Call a Hero V. The Ballad-Monger--Fetter Lane VI. Of Kensington Gardens VII. The Voyage of the Good Ship Albatross VIII. The Fateful Ticket-Puncher IX. The Art of Hieroglyphics X. The Need for Intuition XI. A Side-Light Upon Appearances XII. The Chapel of Unredemption XIII. The Inventory XIV. The Way to Find Out XV. What is Hidden by a Camisole XVI. Easter Sunday XVII. The Fly in the Amber XVIII. The Nonsense-Maker XIX. The Mr. Chesterton XX. Why Jill Prayed To St. Joseph XXI. The City Of Beautiful Nonsense
XXII. The Heart of the Shadow XXIII. Amber
XXIV. The Palazzo Capello XXV. The Letter--Venice XXVI. The Return--Venice XXVII. The True Mother XXVIII. The Treasure Shop XXIX. The Candle for St. Anthony XXX. The Qualities of Ignatia XXXI. The Sacrifice XXXII. The Departure--Venice XXXIII. The 16th of February--London XXXIV. The Dissoluble Bondage XXXV. The Wonder of Belief XXXVI. The Passing XXXVII. The Circular Tour XXXVIII. A Process of Honesty XXXIX. The End of the Loom
The City of Beautiful Nonsense
A PRELUDE ON THE EVE OF ST. JOSEPH’S DAY
Of course, the eighteenth of March--but it is out of the question to say upon which day of the week it fell.
It was half-past seven in the evening. At half-past seven it is dark, the lamps are lighted, the houses huddle together in groups. They have secrets to tell as soon as it is dark. Ah! If you knew the secrets that houses are telling when the shadows draw them so close together! But you never will know. They close their eyes and they whisper.
Around the fields of Lincoln’s Inn it was as still as the grave. The footsteps of a lawyer’s clerk hurrying late away from chambers vibrated through the intense quiet. You heard each step to the very last. So long as you could see him, you heard them plainly; then he vanished behind the curtain of shadows, the sounds became muffled, and at last the silence crept back into the Fields--crept all round you, half eager, half reluctant, like sleepy children drawn from their beds to hear the end of a fairy story.
There was a fairy story to be told, too.
It began that night of the eighteenth of March--the Eve of St. Joseph’s day.
I don’t know what it is about St. Joseph, but of all those saints who crowd their hallowed names upon the calendar--and, good heavens! there are so many--he seems most worthy of canonisation. In the fervent fanaticism of faith, the virtue of a martyr’s death is almost its own reward; but to live on in the belief of that miracle which offers to crush marital happiness, scattering family honour like dust before the four winds of heaven--that surely was the noblest martyrdom of all.
There is probably enough faith left in some to-day to give up their lives for their religion; but I know of no man who would allow his faith to intercede for the honour of his wife’s good name when once the hand of circumstance had played so conjuring a trick upon him.
And so, amongst Roman Catholics, who, when it comes to matters of faith, are like children at a fair, even the spirit of condolence seems to have crept its way into their attitude towards this simple-minded man.
"Poor St. Joseph," they say--"I always get what I want from him. I’ve never known him to fail."
Or--"Poor St. Joseph--he’s not a bit of good to me. I always pray to the Blessed Virgin for everything I want."
Could anything be more childlike, more ingenuous, more like a game in a nursery--the only place in the world where things are really believed.
Every saint possesses his own separate quality, efficacious in its own separate way. St. Rock holds the magic philtre of health; you pray to St. Anthony to recover all those things that were lost--and how palpably stand out the times when, rising from your knees, your search was successful, how readily those times drop into oblivion when you failed. It is impossible to enumerate all the saints and their qualities crowding the pages of those many volumes of _Butler’s Lives_. For safety at sea, for instance, St. Gerald is unsurpassed; but St. Joseph--poor St. Joseph!--from him flow all those good things which money can buy--the children’s toys, the woman’s pin money and the luxuries which are the necessities of the man.
Think, if you can--if you can conjure before your mind’s eye--of all the things that must happen on that eve of the feast day of St. Joseph. How many thousands of knees are bent, how many thousand jaded bodies and hungry souls whisper the name of poor St. Joseph? The prayers for that glitter of gold, that shine of silver and that jangling of copper are surely too numerous to count. What a busy day it must be where those prayers are heard! What hopes must be born that night and what responsibilities lightened! Try and count the candles that are lighted before the shrine of St. Joseph! It is impossible.
It all resolves itself into a simple mathematical calculation. Tell me how many poor there are--and I will tell you how many candles are burnt, how many prayers are prayed, and how many hopes are born on the eve of St. Joseph’s day.
And how many poor are there in the world?
The bell was toning for eight o’clock Benediction at the Sardinia St. Chapel on that evening of the eighteenth of March--Sardinia St. Chapel, which stands so tremulously in the shadows of Lincoln’s Inn Fields--tremulously, because any day the decision of the council of a few men may rase it ruthlessly to the ground.
Amongst all the figures kneeling there in the dim candle-light, their shoulders hunched, their heads sinking deeply in their hands, there was not one but on whose lips the name of poor St. Joseph lingered in earnest or piteous appeal.
These were the poor of the earth, and who and what were they?
There was a stock-broker who paid a rent of some three hundred pounds a year for his offices in the City, a rent of one hundred and fifty for his chambers in Temple Gardens, and whose house in the country was kept in all the splendour of wealth.
Behind him--he sat in a pew by himself--was a lady wearing a heavy fur coat. She was young. Twenty-three at the utmost. There was nothing to tell from her, but her bent head, that the need of money could ever enter into her consideration. She also was in a pew alone. Behind her sat three servant girls. On the other side of the aisle, parallel with the lady in the fur coat, there was a young man--a writer--a journalist--a driver of the pen, whose greatest source of poverty was his ambition.
Kneeling behind him at various distances, there were a clerk, a bank manager, a charwoman; and behind all these, at the end of the chapel, devout, intent, and as earnest as the rest, were four Italian organ-grinders.
These are the poor of the earth. They are not a class. They are every class. Poverty is not a condition of some; it is a condition of all. Those things we desire are so far removed from those which we obtain, that all of us are paupers. And so, that simple arithmetical problem must remain unsolved; for it is impossible to tell the poor of this world and, therefore, just so impossible it is to count the candles that are burnt, the prayers that are prayed or the hopes that are born on the eve of St. Joseph’s day.
When the Benediction was over and the priest had passed in procession with the acolytes into the mysterious shadows behind the altar, the little congregation rose slowly to its feet.
One by one they approached the altar of St. Joseph. One by one their pennies rattled into the brown wooden box as they took out their candles, and soon the sconce before the painted image of that simple-minded saint was ablaze with little points of light.
There is nature in everything; as much in lighting candles for poor St. Joseph as you will find in the most momentous decision of a life-time.
The wealthy stock-broker, counting with care two pennies from amongst a handful of silver, was servant to the impulses of his nature. It crossed his mind that they must be only farthing candles--a penny, therefore, was a very profitable return--the Church was too grasping. He would buy no more than two. Why should the Church profit seventy-five per cent. upon his faith? He gave generously to the collection. It may be questioned, too, why St. Joseph should give him what he had asked, a transaction which brought no apparent profit to St. Joseph at all? He did not appreciate that side of it. He had prayed that a speculation involving some thousands of pounds should prove successful. If his prayer were granted, he would be the richer by twenty per cent. upon his investment--but not seventy-five, oh, no--not seventy-five! And so those two pennies assumed the proportions of an exactment which he grudgingly bestowed. They rattled in his ear as they fell.
After him followed the charwoman. Crossing herself, she bobbed before the image. Her money was already in her hand. All through the service, she had gripped it in a perspiring palm, fearing that it might be lost. Three-penny-bits are mischievous little coins. She gave out a gentle sigh of relief when at last she heard it tinkle in the box. It was safe there. That was its destination. The three farthing candles became hers. She lit them lovingly. Three children there were, waiting in some tenement buildings for her return. As she put each candle in its socket, she whispered each separate name--John--Mary--Michael. There was not one for herself.
Then came the clerk. He lit four. They represented the sum of coppers that he had. It might have bought a packet of cigarettes. He looked pensively at the four candles he had lighted in the sconce, then turned, fatalistically, on his heel. After all, what good could four farthing candles do to poor St. Joseph? Perhaps he had been a fool--perhaps it was a waste of money.
Following him was the bank manager. Six candles he took out of the brown wooden box. Every year he lit six. He had never lit more; he had never lit less. He lit them hurriedly, self-consciously, as though he were ashamed of so many and, turning quickly away, did not notice that the wick of one of them had burnt down and gone out.
The first servant girl who came after him, lifted it out of the socket and lit it at another flame.
"I’m going to let that do for me," she whispered to the servant girl behind her. "I lit it--it ’ud a’ been like that to-morrow if I ’adn’t a’ lit it."
Seeing her companion’s expression of contempt, she giggled nervously. She must have been glad to get away down into the shadows of the church. There, she slipped into an empty pew and sank on to her knees.
"Please Gawd, forgive me," she whispered. "I know it was mean of me," and she tried to summon the courage to go back and light a new candle. But the courage was not there. It requires more courage than you would think.
At last all had gone but the lady in the heavy fur coat and the writer--the journalist--the driver of the pen. There was a flood of light from all the candles at the little altar, the church was empty, everything was still; but there these two remained, kneeling silently in their separate pews.
What need was there in the heart of her that kept her so patiently upon her knees? Some pressing desire, you may be sure--some want that women have and only women understand. And what was the need in him? Not money! Nothing that St. Joseph could give. He had no money. One penny was lying contentedly at the bottom of his pocket. That, at the moment, was all he had in the world. It is mostly when you have many possessions that you need the possession of more. To own one penny, knowing that there is no immediate possibility of owning another, that is as near contentment as one can well-nigh reach.
Then why did he wait on upon his knees? What was the need in the heart of him? Nature again--human nature, too--simply the need to know the need in her. That was all.
Ten minutes passed. He watched her through the interstices of his fingers. But she did not move. At last, despairing of any further discovery than that you may wear a fur coat costing thirty guineas and still be poor, still pray to St. Joseph, he rose slowly to his feet.
Almost immediately afterwards, she followed him.
He walked directly to the altar and his penny had jangled in the box before he became aware that there was only one candle left.
He looked back. The lady was waiting. The impulse came in a moment. He stood aside and left the candle where it was. Then he slowly turned away.
There are moments in life when playful Circumstance links hands with a light-hearted Fate, and the two combined execute as dainty an impromptu dance of events as would take the wit of a man some months of thought to rehearse.
Here you have a man, a woman, and a candle destined for the altar of St. Joseph, all flung together in an empty church by the playful hand of Circumstance and out of so strange a medley comes a fairy story--the story of the City of Beautiful Nonsense--a dream or a reality--they are one and the same thing--a little piece of colour in the great patchwork which views the souls still sleeping.
He knew, as he slowly turned away, that the matter did not end there. You must not only be a student of human nature in order to drive a pen. Circumstance must be anticipated as well. There may be nature in everything, but it is the playful hand of Circumstance which brings it to your eyes. So, he slowly turned away--oh, but very slowly--with just so much show of action as was necessary to convey that he had no intention to remain.
But every sense in him was ready for the moment when her voice arrested him.
"You have not," said she, "taken the candle that you paid for." Her voice was low to a whisper.
He came round on his heel at once.
"No--it’s the last. I didn’t notice that when I dropped my penny in."
"But you ought to take it."
"But why should you?"
"It seemed possible that you might want to light it more than I did."
What did he mean by that? That she was poor, poorer than he? That the generosity of St. Joseph was of greater account to her? It was. It must be surely. No one could need more sorely the assistance of the powers of heaven than she did then.
But why should he know? Why should he think that? Had it been that poor charwoman--oh, yes. But--she looked at his serviceable blue serge suit, compared it instinctively with the luxury of her heavy fur coat--why should he think that of her?
"I don’t see why I should accept your generosity," she whispered.
"I offer it to St. Joseph," said he.
She took up the candle.
"I shouldn’t be surprised if he found your offering the more acceptable of the two."
He watched her light it; he watched her place it in an empty socket. He noticed her hands--delicate--white--fingers that tapered to the dainty finger nails. What could it have been that she had been praying for?
"Well--I don’t suppose St. Joseph is very particular," he said with a humorous twist of the lip.
"Don’t you? Poor St. Joseph!"
She crossed herself and turned away from the altar.
"Now--I owe you a penny," she added.
She held out the coin, but he made no motion to take it.
"I’d rather not be robbed," said he, "of a fraction of my offer to St. Joseph. Would you mind very much if you continued to owe?"
"As you wish." She withdrew her hand. "Then, thank you very much. Good-night."
He walked slowly after her down the church. It had been a delicate stringing of moments on a slender thread of incident--that was all. It had yielded nothing. She left him just as ignorant as before. He knew no better why she had been praying so earnestly to poor St. Joseph.
But then, when you know what a woman prays for, you know the deepest secret of her heart. And it is impossible to learn the deepest secret of a woman’s heart in ten minutes; though you may more likely arrive at it then, than in a life-time.
THE GREENGROCER’S--FETTER LANE
Two or three years ago, there was a certain greengrocer’s shop in Fetter Lane. The front window had been removed, the better to expose the display of fruits and vegetables which were arranged on gradually ascending tiers, completely obstructing your vision into the shop itself. Oranges, bananas, potatoes, apples, dates--all pressed together in the condition in which they had arrived at the London docks, ballast for the good ship that brought them--carrots and cauliflowers, all in separate little compartments, were huddled together on the ascending rows of shelves like colours that a painter leaves negligently upon his palette.
At night, a double gas jet blew in the wind just outside, deepening the contrasts, the oranges with the dull earth brown of the potatoes, the bright yellow bananas with the sheen of blue on the green cabbages! Oh, that sheen of blue on the green cabbages! It was all the more beautiful for being an effect rather than a real colour. How an artist would have loved it!
These greengrocers’ shops and stalls are really most picturesque, so much more savoury, too, than any other shop--except a chemist’s. Of course, there is nothing to equal that wholesome smell of brown Windsor soap which pervades even the most cash of all cash chemist’s! An up-to-date fruiterer’s in Piccadilly may have as fine an odour, perhaps; but then an up-to-date fruiterer is not a greengrocer. He does not dream of calling himself such. They are greengrocers in Fetter Lane--greengrocers in the Edgware Road--greengrocers in old Drury, but fruiterers in Piccadilly.
Compared, then, with the ham and beef shop, the fish-monger’s, and the inevitable oil shop, where, in such neighbourhoods as these, you buy everything, this greengrocer’s was a welcome oasis in a desert of unsavoury smells and gloomy surroundings. The colours it displayed, the brilliant flame of that pyramid of oranges, those rosy cheeks of the apples, that glaring yellow cluster of bananas hanging from a hook in the ceiling, and the soft green background of cabbages, cauliflowers and every other green vegetable which chanced to be in season, with one last touch of all, some beetroot, cut and bleeding, colour that an emperor might wear, combined to make that little greengrocer’s shop in Fetter Lane the one saving clause in an otherwise dreary scheme. It cheered you as you passed it by. You felt thankful for it. Those oranges looked clean and wholesome. They shone in the light of that double gas jet. They had every reason to shine. Mrs. Meakin rubbed them with her apron every morning when she built up that perilous pyramid. She rubbed the apples, too, until their faces glowed, glowed like children ready to start for school. When you looked at them you thought of the country, the orchards where they had been gathered, and Fetter Lane, with all its hawkers’ cries and screaming children, vanished from your senses. You do not get that sort of an impression when you look in the window of a ham and beef shop. A plate of sliced ham, on which two or three flies crawl lazily, a pan of sausages, sizzling in their own fat, bear no relation to anything higher than the unfastidious appetite of a hungry man.
That sort of shop, you pass by quickly; but, even if you had not wished to buy anything, you might have hesitated, then stopped before Mrs. Meakin’s little greengrocer’s stall in Fetter Lane.
The novel opens with a precise temporal marker—'the eighteenth of March'—only to immediately undermine it: 'it is out of the question to say upon which day of the week it fell.' This deliberate vagueness sets the tone for a narrative that prioritizes atmosphere over chronology. The prose in the first chapter is hushed and secretive, with houses that 'huddle together' and 'whisper' their secrets. The silence of Lincoln's Inn Fields is broken only by the footsteps of a lawyer's clerk, each step 'vibrated through the intense quiet.' This careful attention to sound and stillness establishes a slow, almost breathless pace that contrasts sharply with later passages.
The Rhythm of Secrets and Shadows
The opening chapters are dominated by a sense of withheld information. The narrator directly addresses the reader, confessing ignorance about St. Joseph's day and hinting at a 'fairy story' to come. The prose lingers on details—the 'curtain of shadows,' the 'sleepy children' simile—creating a languid, anticipatory rhythm. This is a voice that savors mystery, as seen in the repeated motif of secrets: houses have them, characters harbor them, and the narrative itself seems reluctant to reveal its hand. The pace is unhurried, almost meditative, inviting the reader to dwell in the uncertainty.
A Shift in Voice: From Whisper to Romance
When John describes Venice to Jill, the narrative voice undergoes a marked transformation. The clipped, observational tone of the London scenes gives way to a lyrical, almost incantatory style. John's speech is a set-piece of romantic description: 'a city of slender towers and white domes, sleeping in the water like a mass of water lilies.' The sentences grow longer, more rhythmic, and the imagery becomes lush and sensory—'dark water-ways, mysterious threads of shadow,' 'the plash of the gondolier's oar.' This shift is not merely a change in subject but a deliberate modulation of pace, from the constrained quiet of Fetter Lane to the expansive, dreamlike evocation of Venice.
The Interplay of Dialogue and Description
Thurston uses dialogue to control the narrative tempo. In the excerpt, Jill's questions—'What is she like?'—prompt John's extended reverie, which in turn slows the scene to a near-halt. The conversation becomes a vehicle for the novel's central tension: the pull between present duty and imagined future. The dialogue itself is marked by pauses and hesitations, as when Jill 'tried in one grasp of her mind to hold all that that meant.' These moments of introspection create a counterpoint to the descriptive passages, giving the narrative a breathing rhythm. The result is a voice that oscillates between intimate exchange and panoramic vision, never settling into a single register.
Readers attuned to shifts in narrative pace will find in The City of Beautiful Nonsense a work that moves between two poles: the constrained, secret-laden world of London and the expansive, romanticized Venice of John's imagination. The novel's voice is never static; it modulates with each scene, using silence and speech, shadow and light, to create a texture that rewards close attention to its cadences.
I keep thinking about that quiet chapter in Lincoln’s Inn Fields, how secrets hang there like held breath, and then Venice loosens everything into light. It reminded me of the slow way the Gulf unfolds in Gunboat and Gun-runner: A Tale of the Persian Gulf — Text and Context—same shadowed patience, urging nothing, just letting places breathe their own truth.
Daniel Rodriguez
1 month agoSofia Campbell
1 week agoIsabella Scott
1 week agoJack Smith
1 month agoHow did this book work for you?
Your answers remain private and are stored only in this browser.
Carter Torres
3 weeks ago