Pabo, the Priest: A Novel — Reading Notes

(0 User reviews)   93
Baring-Gould, S. (Sabine), 1834-1924 Project Gutenberg 2013
Wales -- Fiction; Priests -- Fiction; Great Britain -- History -- Henry I, 1100-1135 -- Fiction Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words: 55,519
Reading time: 242 min
Text sections: 6
In 12th-century Wales, Archpriest Pabo faces Norman encroachment and internal betrayal. The novel opens with King Henry I's dyspepsia treated as a salamander infestation, then shifts to a tense assembly where a Norman lord forces Welshmen to draw lots for hanging. Baring-Gould contrasts superstitious court medicine with brutal colonial justice.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.7/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

There were in the room in the palace of Westminster others besides the King and the imprisoned salamander. Henry had sent into South Wales for Gerald de Windsor and his wife Nest. These two were now in the chamber with the sick King.

"There, Nest," said he, "look at yon beast. Study it well. It is called a porcupine. Plinius asserts--I think it is Plinius--that when angered he sets all his quills in array and launches one at the eyes of such as threaten or assail him. Therefore, when I approach the cage, I carry a bolster before me as a buckler."

"Prithee, Sire, when thou didst go against the Welsh last year, didst thou then as well wear a bolster?"

"Ah," said the King, "you allude to the arrow that was aimed at me, and which would have transfixed me but for my hauberk. That was shot by no Welshman."

"Odds life, Nest, there be many who would prefer to have the light and lax hand of Robert over them than mine, which is heavy, and grips tightly."

"Then I counsel, when thou warrest against the Welsh, wear a pillow strapped behind as well as one before."

"Nest! Thy tongue is sharp as a spine of the porcupine. Get thee gone into the embrasure, and converse with the parrot there. Gerald and I have some words to say to each other, and when I have done with him, then I will speak with thee."

The lady withdrew into the window. She was a beautiful woman, known to be the most beautiful in Wales. She was the daughter of Rhys, King of Dyfed--that is, South Wales, and she had been surrendered when quite young as a hostage to Henry. He had respected neither her youth nor her helpless position away from her natural protectors. Then he had thrust her on Gerald of Windsor, one of the Norman adventurers who were turned loose on Wales to be the oppressors, the plunderers, and the butchers of Nest's own people.

Nest had profuse golden hair, and a wonderful complexion of lilies and roses, that flashed, even flamed with emotion. Her eyes were large and deep, under dark brows, and with long dark lashes that swept her cheeks and veiled her expressive eyes when lowered. She was tall and willowy, graceful in her every movement. In her eyes, usually tremulous and sad, there scintillated a lurking fire--threats of a blaze, should she be angered. When thrown into the arms of Gerald, her wishes had not been consulted. Henry had desired to be rid of her, as an encumbrance, as soon as he resolved on marrying Mathilda, the heiress of the Saxon kings, daughter of Malcolm of Scotland, and niece to Edgar Etheling. At one time he had thought of conciliating the Welsh by making Nest his wife. Their hostility would cease when the daughter of one of their princes sat on the English throne. But on further consideration, he deemed it more expedient for him to attach to him the English, and so rally about him a strong national party against the machinations of his elder brother, Robert. This concluded, he had disposed of Nest, hurriedly, to the Norman Gerald.

Meanwhile, her brother, Griffith, despoiled of his kingdom, a price set on his head, was an exile and a refugee at the Court of the King of Gwynedd, or North Wales, at Aberfraw in Anglesey.

"Come now, Gerald, what is thy report? How fares it with the pacification of Wales?"

"Pacification, Lord King! Do you call that pacifying a man when you thrash his naked body with a thorn-bush?"

"If you prefer the term--subjugation."

"The word suits. Sire, it was excellent policy, as we advanced, to fill in behind us with a colony of Flemings. The richest and fattest land has been cleared of the Welsh and given to foreigners. Moreover, by this means we have cut them off from access to the sea, from their great harbors. It has made them mad. Snatch a meal from a dog, and he will snarl and bite. Now we must break their teeth and cut their claws. They are rolled back among their tangled forests and desolate mountains."

"And what advance has been made?"

"I have gone up the Towy and have established a castle at Carreg Cennen, that shall check Dynevor if need be."

"Why not occupy Dynevor, and build there?"

Gerald looked askance at his wife. The expression of his face said more than words. She was trifling with the bird, and appeared to pay no attention to what was being said.

"I perceive," spoke Henry, and chuckled.

Dynevor had been the palace in which Nest's father, the King of South Wales, had held court. It was from thence that her brother Griffith had been driven a fugitive to North Wales.

"In Carreg Cennen there is water--at Dynevor there is none," said Gerald, with unperturbed face.

"A good reason," laughed Henry, and shifted the pillow behind his head. "Hey, there, Nest! employ thy energies in catching of flies. Methinks were I to put a bluebottle in my mouth, the buzzing might attract the salamander, and I would catch him as he came after it." Then to Gerald, "Go on with thine account."

"I have nothing further to say--than this."

He put forth his hand and took a couple of fresh walnuts off a leaf that was on the table. Then, unbidden, he seated himself on a stool, with his back to the embrasure, facing the King. Next he cracked the shells in his fist, and cast the fragments into the fire. He proceeded leisurely to peel the kernels, then extended his palm to Henry, offering one, but holding his little and third finger over the other.

"I will have both," said Beauclerk.

"Nay, Sire, I am not going to crack all the nutshells, and you eat all the kernels."

"Hitherto I and other adventurers have risked our lives, and shed our blood in cracking the castles of these Welsh fellows, and now we want something more, some of the flesh within. Nay, more. We ask you to help us. You have done nothing."

"I led an army into Wales last summer," said Henry angrily.

"And led it back again," retorted Windsor drily. "Excuse my bluntness. That was of no advantage whatsoever to us in the south. Your forces were not engaged. It was a promenade through Powys. As for us in the south, we have looked for help and found none since your great father made a pilgrimage to St. David. Twice to Dewi is as good as once to Rome, so they say. He went once to look around him and to overawe those mountain wolves."

"What would you have done for you?" inquired Henry surlily.

"Not a great thing for you; for us--everything."

"At this moment a chance offers such as may not return again in our time. If what I propose be done, you drive a knife into the heart of the enemy, and that will be better than cutting off his fingers and toes and slicing away his ears. It will not cost you much, Sire--not the risk of an arrow. Naught save the stroke of a pen."

"The Bishop of St. David's is dead, a Welsh prelate, and the Church there has chosen another Welshman, Daniel, to succeed him. Give the see to an Englishman or a Norman, it matters not which--not a saint, but a fellow on whom you can rely to do your work and ours."

"I see not how this will help you," said Henry, with his eye on the hard face of Gerald, which was now becoming animated, so that the bronze cheek darkened.

"How this will help us!" echoed Windsor. "It will be sovereign as help. See you, Sire! We stud the land with castles, but we cannot be everywhere. The Welsh have a trick of gathering noiselessly in the woods and glens and drawing a ring about one of our strongholds, and letting no cry for assistance escape. Then they close in and put every Englishman therein to the sword--if they catch a Fleming, him they hang forthwith. We know not that a castle has been attacked and taken till we see the clouds lit up with flame. When we are building, then our convoys are intercepted, our masons are harassed, our limekilns are destroyed, our cattle carried off, our horses houghed, and our men slaughtered."

"But what will a bishop avail you in such straits?"

"Attend! and you shall hear. A bishop who is one of ourselves and not a Welshman drains the produce of the land into English pockets. He will put an Englishman into every benefice, that in every parish we may have a spy on their actions, maintained by themselves. There is the joke of it. We will plant monasteries where we have no castles, and stuff them with Norman monks. A bishop will find excuses, I warrant you, for dispossessing the native clergy, and of putting our men into their berths. He will do more. He will throw such a net of canon law over the laity as to entangle them inextricably in its meshes, and so enable us, without unnecessary bloodshed, to arrogate their lands to ourselves."

"Give us the right man. No saint with scruples."

"'Sdeath!" exclaimed the King; "I know the very man for you."

"Bernard, the Queen's steward."

"I can make him one."

"He can cast off his wife--a big-mouthed jade. By my mother's soul, he will be glad to purchase a bishopric so cheap."

"He has been steward to one," mocked Henry. "My Maude postures as a saint, gives large alms to needy clerks, washes the feet of beggars, endows monasteries, and grinds her tenants till they starve, break out into revolt, and have to be hung as an example. She lavishes coin on foreign flattering minstrels--and for that the poor English churl must be put in the press. It is Bernard, and ever Bernard, who has to turn the screw and add the weights and turn the grindstone."

"And he scruples not?"

"Has not a scruple in his conscience. He cheats his mistress of a third of what he raises for her to lavish on the Church and the trumpeters of her fame."

"That is the man we require. Give us Bernard, and, Sire, you will do more to pacify Wales--pacify is your word--than if you sent us an army. Yet it must be effected speedily, before the Welsh get wind of it, or they will have their Daniel consecrated and installed before we shall be ready with our Bernard."

"It shall be accomplished at once--to-morrow. Go, Gerald, make inquiry what bishops are in the city, and send one or other hither. He shall priest him to-morrow, and Bernard shall be consecrated bishop the same day. Take him back with you. If you need men you shall have them. Enthrone him before they are aware. They have been given Urban at Llandaff, and, death of my soul! he has been belaboring his flock with his crook, and has shorn them so rudely that they are bleeding to death. There is Hervey, another Norman we have thrust into St. Asaph, and, if I mistake not, his sheep have expelled their shepherd. So, to support Bernard, force will be required. Let him be well sustained."

"I go," said Gerald. "When opposition is broken we shall eat our walnuts together, Sire."

"Aye--but Bernard will take the largest share."

King Henry folded his hands over his paunch, leaned back and laughed heartily.

"'Sdeath!" said he. "But I believe the salamander has perished: he could not endure the mirth of it. Odds blood! But Bernard will be a veritable salamander in the rude bowels of Wales."

Before him stood Nest, with fire erupting from her dark eyes.

Henry looked at her, raised his brows, settled himself more easily in his chair, but cast aside the pillows on which his arms had rested. "Ha! Nest, I had forgotten thy presence. Hast caught me a bluebottle? My trouble is not so acute just now. How fares our boy, Robert?"

She swept the question aside with an angry gesture of the hand.

"And what sort of housekeeping do you have with Gerald?" he asked.

Again she made a movement of impatience.

"Odds life!" said he. "When here it was ever with thee Wales this, and Wales that. We had no mountains like thy Welsh Mynyddau--that is the silly word, was it not? And no trees like those in the Vale of Towy, and no waters that brawled and foamed like thy mountain brooks, and no music like the twanging of thy bardic harps, and no birds sang so sweet, and no flowers bloomed so fair. Pshaw! now thou art back among them all again. I have sent thee home--art content?"

"You have sent me back to blast and destroy my people. You have coupled my name with that of Gerald, that the curses of my dear people when they fall on him may fall on me also."

"Bah!" said the King. "Catch me a bluebottle, and do not talk in such high terms."

"Henry," she said, in thrilling tones, "I pray you----"

"You were forever praying me at one time to send you back to Wales. I have done so, and you are not content."

"I had rather a thousand times have buried my head--my shamed, my dishonored head"--she spoke with sternness and concentrated wrath--"in some quiet cloister, than to be sent back with a firebrand into my own land to lay its homesteads in ashes."

"You do pretty well among yourselves in that way," said Henry contemptuously. "When were you ever known to unite? You are forever flying at each other's throats and wasting each other's lands. Those who cannot combine must be broken."

Nest drew a long breath. She knitted her hands together.

"Henry," she said, "I pray you, reconsider what Gerald has advised, and withhold consent."

"Nay, it was excellent counsel."

"It was the worst counsel that could be given. Think what has been done to my poor people. You have robbed them of their corn-land and have given it to aliens. You have taken from them their harbors, and they cannot escape. You have driven away their princes, and they cannot unite. You have crushed out their independence, and they cease to be men. They have but one thing left to them as their very own--their Church. And now you will plunder them of that--thrust yourselves in between them and God. They have had hitherto their own pastors, as they have had their own princes. They have followed the one in war and the other in peace. Their pastors have been men of their own blood, of their own speech, men who have suffered with them, have wept with them, and have even bled with them. These have spoken to them when sick at heart, and have comforted them when wounded in spirit. And now they are to be jostled out of their places, to make room for others, aliens in blood, ignorant of our language, indifferent to our woes; men who cannot advise nor comfort, men from whom our people will receive no gift, however holy. Deprived of everything that makes life endurable, will you now deprive them of their religion?"

She paused, out of breath, with flaming cheek, and sparkling eyes--quivering, palpitating in every part of her body.

"Nest," said the King, "you are a woman--a fool. You do not understand policy."

"Policy!" she cried scornfully. "What is policy? My people have their faults and their good qualities."

"Faults! I know them, I trow. As to their good qualities, I have them to learn." He shrugged his shoulders contemptuously.

"You know their faults alone," pursued Nest passionately, "because you seek to find them that you may foster and trade on them. That is policy. Policy is to nurture the evil and ignore the good. None know better their own weaknesses than do we. But why not turn your policy to helping us to overcome them and be made strong?"

"It is through your own inbred faults that we have gained admission into your mountains. Brothers with you cannot trust brothers----"

"No more than you or Robert can trust each other, I presume," sneered Nest. "An arrow was aimed at you from behind. Who shot it? Not a Welshman, but Robert, or a henchman of Robert. On my honor, you set us a rare example of fraternal affection and unity!"

"It is through your own rivalries that we are able to maintain our hold upon your mountains."

"And because we know you as fomenters of discord--doers of the devil's work--that is why we hate you. Give up this policy, and try another method with us."

"Women cannot understand. Have done!"

"Justice, they say, is figured as a woman; for Justice is pitiful towards feebleness and infirmity. But with you is no justice at all, only rank tyranny--tyranny that can only rule with the iron rod, and drive with the scourge."

"Be silent! My salamander is moving again."

But she would not listen to him. She pursued--

"My people are tender-hearted, loving, loyal, frank. Show them trust, consideration, regard, and they will meet you with open arms. We know now that our past has been one of defeat and recoil, and we also know why it has been so. Divided up into our little kingdoms, full of rivalries, jealousies, ambitions, we have not had the wit to cohere. Who would weave us into one has made a rope of sand. It was that, not the superior courage or better arms of the Saxon, that drove us into mountains and across the sea. It is through playing with, encouraging this, bribing into treachery, that you are forcing your way among us now. But if in place of calling over adventurers from France and boors from Flanders to kill us and occupy our lands, you come to us with the olive branch, and offer us your suzerainty and guarantee us against internecine strife--secure to us our lands, our laws, our liberties--then we shall become your devoted subjects, we shall look up to you as to one who raises us, whereas now we regard you as one who casts us down to trample on us. We have our good qualities, and these qualities will serve you well if you will encourage them. But your policy is to do evil, and evil only."

Henry Beauclerk, with a small mallet, struck a wooden disk, and an attendant appeared.

"Call Gerald Windsor back," said he; then, to himself, "this woman is an offense to me."

"Because I utter that which you cannot understand. I speak of justice, and you understand only tyranny."

"Another word, Nest, and I shall have you forcibly removed."

She cast herself passionately at the King's feet.

"I beseech thee--I--I whom thou didst so cruelly wrong when a poor helpless hostage in thy hands--I, away from father and mother--alone among you--not knowing a word of your tongue. I have never asked for aught before. By all the wrongs I have endured from thee--by thy hopes for pardon at the great Day when the oppressed and fatherless will be righted--I implore thee--withhold thy consent."

"It is idle to ask this," said Henry coldly, "Leave me. I will hear no more." Then taking the ewer, he began again to pour water into the basin, and next to ladle it back into the vessel whence he had poured it.

"Oh, you beau clerk!" exclaimed Nest, rising to her feet. "So skilled in books, who knowest the qualities of the porcupine through Plinius, and how to draw forth a salamander, as instructed by Galen! A beau clerk indeed, who does not understand the minds of men, nor read their hearts; who cannot understand their best feelings, whose only thought is that of the churl, to smash, and outrage, and ruin. A great people, a people with more genius in its little finger than all thy loutish Saxons in their entire body, thou wilt oppress, and turn their good to gall, their sweetness to sour, and nurture undying hate where thou mightest breed love."

"Begone! I will strike and summon assistance, and have thee removed."

"Then," said Nest, "I appeal unto God, that He may avenge the injured and the oppressed. May He smite thee where thou wilt most painfully feel the blow! May He break down all in which thou hast set thy hopes, and level with the dust that great ambition of thine!" She gasped. "Sire, when thou seest thy hopes wrecked and thyself standing a stripped and blasted tree--then remember Wales!"

The novel begins not in Wales but in the sick-chamber of King Henry I, where the monarch's indigestion is diagnosed as a salamander lodged in his gut—a creature grown from spawn he supposedly drank. The king's leech prescribes salt pork and a ritual of pouring water between ewer and basin, a cure meant to coax the reptile out. This grotesque medical fantasy sets the tone for a story that moves between Norman court and Welsh hill-country, where different kinds of belief and coercion collide.

From the king's chamber the narrative shifts to a gathering of the men of Caio, summoned before the Norman lord Rogier. Here the threat is not a mythical beast but a steel cap filled with willow twigs, some marked with a death's head. The men must draw lots; those who pick a marked twig will be hanged. The scene is a study in enforced silence and dread, as the community waits for the sun to cross a line before the drawing begins.

Two Kinds of Authority

The excerpts present two contrasting exercises of power. King Henry's authority is personal, hypochondriac, and mediated by a leech who explains his discomfort as a salamander. The cure is elaborate but absurd—a performance of control over an invisible threat. In Wales, Rogier's authority is blunt and collective: he forces the men of Caio to draw lots for execution, using a bassinet of twigs. The king's salamander is a private delusion; Rogier's gallows are public and numerical. Both rulers, however, rely on a kind of theater: the king pours water to fool a reptile, Rogier stages a lottery to break a community's resistance.

The Welshmen, for their part, respond with a different kind of performance. They have already staged a fake funeral, burning a substitute body to make the Normans believe Pabo is dead. When accused of hiding him, they protest ignorance with a chorus of denials. The novel thus sets up a layered conflict between Norman force and Welsh cunning, between open coercion and covert resistance.

The Weight of Custom and Coin

Before the lot-drawing, the men of Caio negotiate a fine. The dispute turns on an ancient Welsh legal principle: the chief bears one-third of a penalty, the community two-thirds. Rogier dismisses this as quibbling, interested only in the silver. The translator relays the argument, but Rogier laughs and says, "So long as I have the silver to hand to the bishop, it is indifferent to me whether you bleed your own veins or fleece your pastor." The line reveals a Norman lord who sees Welsh custom as a nuisance, not a binding code.

The negotiation is conducted through an interpreter, a detail that underscores the linguistic and cultural gulf. The men of Caio speak Welsh; Rogier speaks Norman French or Latin. The interpreter becomes a pivot point, translating not just words but legal concepts that the Norman finds absurd. The scene captures a moment when two legal worlds meet—one based on inherited status and communal obligation, the other on brute possession and the power to demand payment.

Objects That Carry Meaning

Several objects in the excerpts function as focal points for tension. The porcupine, a gift from the King of Denmark, sits in a wicker cage in Henry's chamber—a curiosity that distracts the king from his imagined ailment. The ewer and basin are props in a medical ritual. The bassinet—a steel cap—becomes a vessel for lots, transforming a piece of armor into an instrument of random death. The staff of Cynwyl, a relic that might have been used for oaths, has been stolen, removing a trusted means of swearing truth.

These objects are not merely decorative. They are tools of authority, deception, or belief. The porcupine is a diplomatic gift that also signals the king's taste for the exotic. The ewer and basin are turned to a superstitious purpose. The bassinet is repurposed from protection to selection for execution. The stolen staff leaves the community without a sacred guarantor of oaths. Each object carries a history of use that the novel exploits to reveal character and conflict.

The excerpts offer a narrow but vivid window into Baring-Gould's method: he juxtaposes the Norman court's credulity with Welsh communal resilience, using concrete objects and legal procedures to dramatize power. Readers should attend to the role of interpreters, the weight of customary law, and the way physical things—a cap, a staff, a porcupine—become charged with meaning. The novel's full arc, including Pabo's fate and the resolution of the lot-drawing, remains to be discovered, but the groundwork of tension is laid with precision.

I keep thinking about that moment in Pabo, the Priest where the Norman lord makes the Welshmen draw lots, and how the book never quite lets you forget the weight of a choice that isn't yours. The Judgment Books: A Story — Context and Discussion left a similar ache when I finished it, a quiet wondering about who gets to write the verdicts we live under.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
  • ...
    Herbert Steven Kent - 1 week ago
    {'content': "Pabo The Priest is a masterfully crafted novel that explores the inner turmoil of a man torn between faith and desire. The author's deep understanding of human psychology shines through every page, making Pabo's struggles palpably real. The setting, a small French village, is rendered with authenticity, and the supporting characters add layers of complexity. A thought-provoking and beautifully written piece of literature that lingers long after the final page."}

  • ...
    Joanna Stanton - 1 week ago
    {'content': "Pabo The Priest suffers from a lack of plot and a meandering narrative that fails to engage. The protagonist's internal conflict becomes repetitive, and the author's frequent philosophizing interrupts any chance of forward momentum. The characters are underdeveloped, and the ending feels abrupt and unsatisfying. While the prose is occasionally beautiful, it's not enough to compensate for a story that never quite comes to life."}

  • ...
    Gregory Walker - 5 days ago
    {'content': "This novel offers a compelling look at a priest's crisis of faith, with strong character development and a vivid setting. The prose is elegant, and the themes are timeless. However, the pacing is uneven, with some sections feeling overly introspective and slow. The supporting cast, though interesting, are not fully fleshed out. It's a literary work that will appeal to those who enjoy psychological drama, but others might find it heavy going."}


Reader reflection

What did you think of this book?

Answer a few questions and save a private reflection on this device.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

Which reading stage best describes you?

2

How did the book work for you overall?

3

Would you pass this book on to a friend?

4

How demanding did the text feel?

Related eBooks